Chris Huhne and the cost of desiring power

Chris Huhne could have been leader of the Liberal Democrats.

Well that is, if you believe the unofficial stories that during the 2007 Liberal Democrat leadership election he actually received more votes than Nick Clegg.  The recorded result shows that Clegg narrowly won, but allegedly up to 1300 papers were not counted because they arrived late due to the Christmas post.  If these had been taken into account Huhne would have come out on top.  If this had been the case and a few more Lib Dem voters had not left things to the last minute, we could have had an even more momentous news story from the last week.  Having a Deputy Prime Minister being sent to jail for perverting the course of justice would have been a huge PR disaster for the already battered reputation of politicians.  Undoubtedly there will be plenty of Lib Dem MPs and supporters at the moment who are extremely thankful this never turned out to be the case.

If you want an example of how to completely ruin your life, you don’t need to look much further than Chris Huhne.  Not only is he facing a prison sentence for finally admitting after almost two years of repeated denials that his then wife, Vicky
Pryce, had taken speeding points for him back in 2003, but his political career and reputation have been completely destroyed.  His son’s relationship with him as revealed in the text messages that have been published in the last few days has been replaced with contempt and hatred that looks like it could well be impossible to reconcile.  His ex-wife is still in the middle of a court battle to establish whether she was coerced into taking his points.  Whatever happens with her case, she will have taken plenty of public humiliation too.  The discussion of Pryce’s desire to get revenge following Huhne’s affair that wrecked his marriage illustrates what a horrendous amount of pain has been inflicted by Huhne on the people he should care about the most.

The point of writing this is not to carry out a character assassination of Chris Huhne (he’s done a thorough job of finishing his own career without any help), but rather ask what we should expect from our leaders in terms of integrity and honesty.  In hindsight lying to the police and public over three penalty points for speeding rather than coming clean would appear to be a very stupid mistake or worse.  As it was he still ended up being disqualified from driving later that year after he was caught using his mobile phone whilst driving.  Is someone who has a history of deceit and manipulation the sort of person we want in government or any other position of authority?  Or should we be allowing our politicians the freedom to do what they like in their personal lives as long as they do their professional job well?  Nick Clegg this week has said: “Whatever anyone may think of Chris Huhne, everybody will tell you locally he was an extremely good local MP.”

Nicky Gumbel, rector of Holy Trinity Brompton and of Alpha fame has this to say in his book, ‘The Jesus Lifestyle’:

‘In today’s society there is a common fallacy that we need to make a distinction between people’s private and public lives.  For example, some believe that what politicians do in their private lives won’t affect their public lives.  However, if a politician is unfaithful to his wife in private, inevitably this does relate to what they do and say in public.  If someone can deceive their spouse, who should be the most important person in their life, how can we the general public trust what they say and do?

‘We should live our lives as if everything will be disclosed.  Our personal and professional lives form a single whole.  Life cannot be divided into compartments.  God sees the whole of our lives.  We are called to live and act with integrity wherever we are, no matter whom we are with and whoever is watching.’

In a similar vein, Paul in his letter to Timothy writes this about overseers in the church:

‘Here is a trustworthy saying: Whoever aspires to be an overseer desires a noble task.  Now the overseer is to be above reproach, faithful to his wife, temperate, self-controlled, respectable, hospitable, able to teach, not given to drunkenness, not violent but gentle, not quarrelsome, not a lover of money.  He must manage his own family well and see that his children obey him, and he must do so in a manner worthy of full respect.   (If anyone does not know how to manage his own family, how can he take care of God’s church?)’ (1 Timothy 3:1-5)

Paul is talking about the Church in this instance, but the principle is that same for any leader.  If you are not a trustworthy person in private, then you will have the same attitudes and principles in public, even if you hide them well.  We can’t have split personalities when it comes to morals.

We have to remember that although we should expect high standards from the people who lead us, we all make mistakes.  We all find ourselves twisting the truth at times or doing things in the heat of the moment we later regret.  None of us is perfect and we shouldn’t expect others to be perfect either.  However you can tell a lot about someone’s character when they have to admit to doing something wrong.  If they are genuinely sorry and are honest about their error then they deserve respect and forgiveness.  If they try to deceive others by producing lies to cover their tracks or still refuse to admit they were wrong then they are only storing up worse consequences and hurt down the line.

There are reasons why Chris Huhne has acted the way that he did.  Was it ambition and success that caused him to cover things up for the sake of his political career?  Was it selfish desire to get what he wanted that caused the break-up of his family?  Power and ambition can be dangerous things.  Leadership should always be about serving others.  It should never be about gaining power and control or building little empires.  This is why the concept of being a career politician is flawed.  If your reasons for becoming a leader are focussed on what you can get out of it, rather than what you can give for the benefit of others, then you will never truly be effective in your role, even if you are competent at fulfilling the job description.  The more leaders lose sight of this or fail to grasp it in the first place, the bigger the risk that they will end up causing harm somewhere down the line, even if it’s not in the explosive fashion that Huhne has.  If Chris Huhne had thought about others more than himself, he would still potentially be doing a lot of valuable work and his life and the lives of those close to him would be in a much better state.

Categories: Integrity, Morals & ethics, Party politics

Tags: , , , , , , ,

7 replies

  1. Clearly Chris Huhne has made some bad and silly judgements here, and yes it is right that he has resigned and will go to jail – perverting the course of justice is serious. And a lot of other stuff you say is right. BUT I think the tone of your comments are a bit over judgemental – there needs to be room here for eventual reconciliation and forgiveness. I suspect a large proportion of us will have taken similar risks in our driving and our relationships – and mostly we get away with it. Mr Huhne has not. But let’s not try to make to big an example out of him. He’s just human!

  2. Nick Clegg this week has said: “Whatever anyone may think of Chris Huhne, everybody will tell you locally he was an extremely good local MP.” A liar a cheat and a bounder. Yes a jolly good MP that. But then again the expense scandal and the ignoring of a courts decision is seen as normal for a lot of todays politicians.

    Yes Andrew Charles Mason he is only human. The thing is he can be forgiven but not if he still thinks its all a jape and nothing of real concern and that it was just a bummer he got found out.

  3. When we are given a position of power, to be ”in charge” there is always that temptation to use it either to feed our own ego or gain some benefit over others, Sometimes we becomes so detached from reality that we think the rules and laws that govern others do not apply to us. Sometimes the higher the position or greater the power the more there is to lose ,financially and in terms of status or reputation. Lying becomes a means by which we attempt to conserve what we have. It is really very human. Trouble is, as in Chris Huhnes case you are invariably found out and shamed or if not selfishness and arrogance grows and the spirit gradually dies within you. There is never ever ever ever any escape when we do wrong.This is what Jesus is banging on about all the time. Keep the ego in check, develop beatitude attitudes and serve others. Its our heart condition that is important. Chris Huhne is suffering now but the good news is with repentance (Be sorry, turn and change ) he could attain greater things because nobody is beyond the transforming power of God

  4. Did anybody else spot the section of the 1967 Abortion Act that listed among the circumstances under which termination of pregnancy is legal in the UK

    ‘When the pregnant woman is married to a prominent member of a mainstream political party who feels that having another baby will jeopardize his career.’?

    Nope. I missed that one too. But, of course, being a prominent MP, Chris Huhne knew the law, and so did the doctor who signed the form – they just chose to ignore it because it wasn’t convenient.

    • Yes I’ve seen that too. I didn’t want to go into that in my post but maybe I should have. That’s possibly the most shocking thing that’s come out of the case.

      • I wish I could say that I was shocked, but I’ve read so many women’s stories that go the same way – they were let down by the men in their lives, they were let down by the medical profession who weren’t really interested in the back story, they were let down by feminists telling them it’s empowering to be ‘in control of your own body’, and now only they have to suffer the deep, deep regret.

        There have even been horrific cases in America of victims of incest held down and forced to go through an abortion against their will. It’s a little known fact that only a minority of rape victims and hardly any incest victims actually want to have an abortion. When pro-choice groups come out with their statistics of the number of women with children who ‘choose’ to have an abortion (thus ‘proving’ that abortion is a decision made by mature women) I often wonder what the real story is – what’s really going on in that marriage?

        “in granting this unconscionable power, it [abortion law] has exposed many women to unjust and selfish demands from their husbands or other sexual partners.” (Mother Theresa)

        • This must also be a terrible time for Chris Huhne’s daughter because now everyone knows that her father wanted her killed.

%d bloggers like this: